A Massachusetts Superior Court judge has ruled that Shannon O’Brien, the former chair of the state’s Cannabis Control Commission (CCC), was wrongfully terminated by State Treasurer Deborah Goldberg. The court’s decision mandates O’Brien’s reinstatement to the position, along with back pay and benefits for the duration of her unlawful dismissal.
In a 50-page ruling issued Tuesday, Judge Robert B. Gordon concluded that O’Brien’s conduct did not meet the legal definition of “gross misconduct” required for removal under state law. The judge emphasized that personal disagreements or perceived abrasiveness do not suffice as grounds for termination. He stated, “The question before the Court is not whether [O’Brien] was abrasive, boorish, inconsiderate, ill-tempered, imprudent and/or otherwise unreasonable,” highlighting that such traits do not meet the statutory criteria for dismissal.
O’Brien, who served as Massachusetts Treasurer from 1999 to 2007 and was the Democratic nominee for governor in 2002, was appointed as CCC chair in August 2022. Her tenure was marred by allegations of racial insensitivity and workplace misconduct, leading to her suspension in September 2023 and subsequent firing in September 2024.
Treasurer Goldberg cited multiple instances of alleged misconduct, including remarks perceived as racially insensitive and creating a hostile work environment. However, Judge Gordon found that the evidence did not substantiate these claims to the extent required for legal termination. The ruling described the case against O’Brien as lacking in substantial evidence, stating that the allegations were “manifestly lacking” and comparing the case to a “house of cards.”
In response to the ruling, O’Brien expressed her intention to return to the CCC and fulfill the remaining two years of her term. A spokesperson stated that she is “pleased to have her good name restored” and looks forward to collaborating with the commission’s executive director and fellow commissioners to advance the agency’s mission.
Treasurer Goldberg has indicated plans to appeal the decision, maintaining that the behavior attributed to O’Brien should not be tolerated in the workplace. She expressed disagreement with the judge’s assessment, stating, “Frankly, we think this judge got it wrong.”
This legal development comes amid broader discussions about the governance and effectiveness of the CCC. A recent legislative proposal seeks to restructure the commission, including provisions to increase the number of cannabis retail licenses and address ongoing concerns about the agency’s operations.
As the situation evolves, stakeholders within Massachusetts’ cannabis industry and regulatory community will be closely monitoring the implications of the court’s decision and any subsequent actions taken by state officials.
Dabbin-Dad Newsroom
